ShabbatAll 2,711 folios of the Talmud Bavli open with Premium, from $2.60 a month.Become a premium member

The Talmud

שַׁבָּת דף ד׳Shabbat 4b

Amud b of Shabbat 4 — the second side of the page

Checking for audio…

English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.

Shabbat 4b · שבת ד׳ ב

ובתוך עשרה פליגי והא מיבעיא בעי לה רבה דבעי רבה למטה מי' פליגי ובהא פליגי דר"ע סבר קלוטה כמי שהונחה דמיא ורבנן סברי לא אמרינן קלוטה כמי שהונחה דמיא אבל למעלה מי' דברי הכל פטור ודכ"ע לא ילפינן זורק ממושיט

— and that they differ within ten handbreadths? But surely Rabbah raised the matter as a question! For Rabbah asked: do they differ below ten handbreadths, and this is what they differ over — that Rabbi Akiva holds an object caught in the air is as though it had been set down and the Rabbis hold we do not say an object caught in the air is as though it had been set down, but above ten handbreadths all agree that he is exempt, and all agree that we do not derive throwing from passing across (the handing of a thing across from one place to another, as the Levites passed the boards between the wagons);

או דילמא למעלה מי' פליגי ובהא פליגי דר"ע סבר ילפינן זורק ממושיט ורבנן סברי לא ילפינן זורק ממושיט אבל למטה מי' דברי הכל חייב מאי טעמא אמרינן קלוטה כמי שהונחה דמיא

or perhaps they differ above ten handbreadths, and this is what they differ over — that Rabbi Akiva holds we do derive throwing from passing across and the Rabbis hold we do not derive throwing from passing across, but below ten handbreadths all agree that he is liable. What is the reason? Because we say an object caught in the air is as though it had been set down.

הא לא קשיא בתר דאיבעי הדר איפשיטא ליה דסבר ר"ע קלוטה כמי שהונחה דמיא

That is not difficult: after he raised the question he then resolved it for himself, that Rabbi Akiva holds an object caught in the air is as though it had been set down.

ודילמא הנחה הוא דלא בעיא הא עקירה בעיא

But perhaps it is only a setting down that is not required, whereas a lifting is required!

…and 5 more passages on this amud.

Become a premium member

Or start free — a free account opens your first 5 gematria searches in full. Create free account

The daily learning is free on your account, every day.

Talmud Bavli, Wikisource edition, via Sefaria — CC BY-SA 4.0. English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.