The Talmud
מעילה דף ב׳Meilah 2b
Amud b of Meilah 2 — the second side of the page
English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.
Meilah 2b · מעילה ב׳ ב
איבעיא להו אי עלו מהו שירדו רבה אמר אם עלו ירדו רב יוסף אמר אם עלו לא ירדו
A question was raised before them: if they went up, what is the law — do they come down? Rabbah said: if they went up, they come down. Rav Yosef said: if they went up, they do not come down.
אליבא דר' יהודה לא תיבעי לך דכ"ע ל"פ דאם עלו ירדו כי פליגי אליבא דר"ש
According to Rabbi Yehuda you need not ask, for all agree that if they went up, they come down. Where they differ is according to Rabbi Shimon.
רב יוסף כר"ש רבה אמר לך עד כאן לא קאמר ר"ש אלא בניתנין למטה שנתנן למעלה או בניתנין למעלה שנתנן למטה
Rav Yosef is in accordance with Rabbi Shimon. And Rabbah could say to you: Rabbi Shimon said that only in the case of those to be placed below which he placed above, or those to be placed above which he placed below.
ולעולם דשחטן וקבל דמן בצפון אבל הכא כיון דשחטן בדרום כמאן דחנקינון דמי
And in truth, that is where he slaughtered them and received their blood in the north; but here, since he slaughtered them in the south, it is as though we had strangled them.
Talmud Bavli, Wikisource edition, via Sefaria — CC BY-SA 4.0. English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.