The Talmud
נדרים דף מ״דNedarim 44b
Amud b of Nedarim 44 — the second side of the page
English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.
Nedarim 44b · נדרים מ״ד ב
ודלמא אתי לעשורי מן החיוב על הפטור ומן הפטור על החיוב
And perhaps he will come to tithe from that which is liable for that which is exempt, and from that which is exempt for that which is liable!
דאמרי' ליה כי מעשרת עשר מיניה וביה
For we say to him: when you tithe, tithe from it and within it.
מיתיבי המפקיר את כרמו ולשחר עמד ובצרו חייב בפרט ובעוללות ובשכחה ובפיאה ופטור מן המעשר
They raised an objection: one who renders his vineyard ownerless and then rose at dawn and harvested it is liable for the single grapes that fall and for the defective clusters, and for the forgotten sheaf and for peah (the corner of the field left to the poor), and is exempt from the tithe.
בשלמא לעולא דרבנן קתני לה ודאורייתא קתני לה אלא לריש לקיש אמאי פטור מן המעשר
Granted according to Ulla: it teaches what is by the word of the Rabbis and it teaches what is by Torah law. But according to Reish Lakish, why is he exempt from the tithe?
Talmud Bavli, Wikisource edition, via Sefaria — CC BY-SA 4.0. English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.