MenachotAll 2,711 folios of the Talmud Bavli open with Premium, from $2.60 a month.Become a premium member

The Talmud

מנחות דף כ״וMenachot 26b

Amud b of Menachot 26 — the second side of the page

Checking for audio…

English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.

Menachot 26b · מנחות כ״ו ב

וחישב עליה בין חוץ למקומו בין חוץ לזמנו פסול ואין בו כרת

— he had an intention concerning it, whether outside its place or outside its time, it is unfit, and there is no karet (excision at the hand of Heaven) for it.

(ל"א) חישב עליה חוץ למקומו פסול ואין בו כרת חוץ לזמנו פיגול וחייבין עליו כרת דברי ר' אלעזר ור"ש

Another version: if he had an intention concerning it outside its place, it is unfit, and there is no karet for it; outside its time, it is piggul (an offering invalidated by a wrong intention at the service), and one is liable to karet for it. These are the words of Rabbi Elazar and Rabbi Shimon.

וחכ"א כיון שנתנו לשמאל פסלתו מתנתו מ"ט משום דבעי קדושה בכלי וכיון שנתנו לשמאל נעשה כדם שנשפך מצואר בהמה על הרצפה ואספו שפסול

And the Sages say: once he has put it into the left, his placing has disqualified it. What is the reason? Because it requires sanctity in a vessel; and once he has put it into the left, it has become like blood that was poured out from the neck of an animal upon the pavement and he gathered it up, which is unfit.

מכלל דר"א ור"ש לא בעו מתן כלי תיובתא דרב נחמן תיובתא

It follows that Rabbi Elazar and Rabbi Shimon do not require the placing in a vessel. This is a refutation of Rav Nachman. It is indeed a refutation.

…and 14 more passages on this amud.

Become a premium member

Or start free — a free account opens your first 5 gematria searches in full. Create free account

The daily learning is free on your account, every day.

Talmud Bavli, Wikisource edition, via Sefaria — CC BY-SA 4.0. English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.