MakkotAll 2,711 folios of the Talmud Bavli open with Premium, from $2.60 a month.Become a premium member

The Talmud

מכות דף ט״וMakkot 15b

Amud b of Makkot 15 — the second side of the page

Checking for audio…

English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.

Makkot 15b · מכות ט״ו ב

מידי הוא טעמא אלא לרבי יוחנן האמר ליה רבי יוחנן לתנא תני בטלו חייב ולא בטלו פטור

Is this an argument against anyone but Rabbi Yochanan? Surely Rabbi Yochanan said to the tanna: teach "he nullified it — he is liable; he did not nullify it — he is exempt".

דתני תנא קמיה דרבי יוחנן כל מצות לא תעשה שיש בה קום עשה קיים עשה שבה פטור ביטל עשה שבה חייב

For a tanna taught before Rabbi Yochanan: every prohibition that carries with it a positive commandment to rise up and act — if he fulfilled the positive commandment in it, he is exempt; if he nullified the positive commandment in it, he is liable.

א"ל מאי קא אמרת קיים פטור לא קיים חייב ביטל חייב לא ביטל פטור תני ביטלו ולא ביטלו ורבי שמעון בן לקיש אומר קיימו ולא קיימו

He said to him: what are you saying — "he fulfilled it, exempt; he did not fulfil it, liable"? "He nullified it, liable; he did not nullify it, exempt"! Teach: "he nullified it" and "he did not nullify it". And Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish says: "he fulfilled it" and "he did not fulfil it".

במאי קא מיפלגי בהתראת ספק קא מיפלגי מר סבר התראת ספק שמה התראה

In what do they differ? They differ over a warning given in a case of doubt (hatra'at safek): one Master holds that a warning given in a case of doubt is a warning;

Become a premium member

Or start free — a free account opens your first 5 gematria searches in full. Create free account

The daily learning is free on your account, every day.

Talmud Bavli, Wikisource edition, via Sefaria — CC BY-SA 4.0. English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.