The Talmud
חולין דף י׳Chullin 10b
Amud b of Chullin 10 — the second side of the page
English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.
Chullin 10b · חולין י׳ ב
ומאי שנא התם איתילידא בה ריעותא בבהמה הכא סכין איתרעאי בהמה לא איתרעאי
And what is different? — There a flaw has arisen in it, in the animal itself; here the knife was flawed, the animal was not flawed.
והילכתא כוותיה דרב הונא כשלא שיבר בה עצם והילכתא כוותיה דרב חסדא כששיבר בה עצם מכלל דרב חסדא אע"ג דלא שיבר בה עצם אלא במאי איפגים אימא בעצם דמפרקת איפגים
And the halachah is in accordance with Rav Huna where he did not break a bone with it, and the halachah is in accordance with Rav Chisda where he did break a bone with it. Does this imply that Rav Chisda holds it fit even where he did not break a bone with it? But then on what was it notched? Say: it was notched on the bone of the nape.
הוה עובדא וטרף רב יוסף עד תליסר חיותא כמאן כרב הונא ואפילו בקמייתא לא כרב חסדא ולבר מקמייתא
There was an incident, and Rav Yosef declared as many as thirteen animals tereifot (animals with a fatal defect). In accordance with whom? In accordance with Rav Huna — and even the first one. No: in accordance with Rav Chisda — and excepting the first one.
ואיבעית אימא לעולם כרב הונא דאי כרב חסדא מכדי מתלא תלינן ממאי דבעצם דמפרקת דקמייתא איפגים דלמא בעצם דמפרקת דבתרייתא איפגים
And if you wish, say: it was really in accordance with Rav Huna. For if it were in accordance with Rav Chisda — since after all we do attribute the notch to a bone, from where do we know that it was on the bone of the nape of the first that it was notched? Perhaps it was on the bone of the nape of the last that it was notched!
Talmud Bavli, Wikisource edition, via Sefaria — CC BY-SA 4.0. English rendering prepared for The Gematria — not a historical translation.